Reviews of Baseball Legacy Manager 24

By: Elie Lamoureux App

List of user reviews and ratings for Baseball Legacy Manager 24

Total ratings

3.70 (Rating count: 54)

Receive review notifications

Get notified when new reviews are posted so you can respond quickly.

See reviews on Apple App Store

View and respond to reviews directly on the store page.

Visit

Review summary

Baseball Legacy Manager 24 offers deep GM-style control and customization with potential for a rich baseball management sim. However, widespread stability bugs, progression blockers, missing core baseball features, and performance/load-time issues prevent reliable play and dampen the experience.

Pros

Deep GM-style control with extensive customization that appeals to management-sim fans
Engaging baseball management experience with potential depth, including noted player development pacing and financial mechanics
Strong customization potential and the sense that the game could shine with continued polish for LM-style fans

Cons

Frequent crashes and freezes causing progress loss and forcing manual saves
Bugs that block progression (season start issues, career loading problems, update-related blockers) making play unreliable
Incomplete baseball feature set and roster management (missing DH, no 40-man roster, missing minor leagues/draft) plus AI roster/lineup issues
Performance concerns and long load times when loading large or custom leagues

Upgrade to see all 19 reviews

User Reviews

Recent rating average: 3.00

All time rating average: 3.70

Upgrade to see all 19 reviews

42% (8)

Date	Author	Comment
2025-03-28	ol*****	You can go past the all star game, the sim crashes and freezes
You can go past the all star game, the sim crashes and freezes
2025-02-04	Ip*****	This is a good game. It allows you to take full control as you would wish in a GM game. The main issue is the constant crashing. You’re lucky to play 10-15 minutes without the game shutting you out. Though it has an auto save feature, I suggest saving manually each time you do something significant (trades, roster upgrades, draft etc)
This is a good game. It allows you to take full control as you would wish in a GM game. The main issue is the constant crashing. You’re lucky to play 10-15 minutes without the game shutting you out. Though it has an auto save feature, I suggest saving manually each time you do something significant (trades, roster upgrades, draft etc)
2024-12-09	lo*****	Won’t open on my Mac
Won’t open on my Mac
2024-11-05	Ma*****	It’s fun your players develop at a good speed and the financial things are good
It’s fun your players develop at a good speed and the financial things are good
2024-09-24	Yl*****	Enjoy this game but currently there is this error where I tried to sim to the all-star game, but the sim progress does not move and stuck
Enjoy this game but currently there is this error where I tried to sim to the all-star game, but the sim progress does not move and stuck
2024-08-21	dk*****	When I found out there was a baseball game I immediately downloaded it and began playing. While the game itself it pretty good compared to what I expected. There was one issue… I kept getting kicked out of my game, leading to all my progress being lost. I want to play to game but I despise the fact that I have to continuously re-save the game over and over every month.
When I found out there was a baseball game I immediately downloaded it and began playing. While the game itself it pretty good compared to what I expected. There was one issue… I kept getting kicked out of my game, leading to all my progress being lost. I want to play to game but I despise the fact that I have to continuously re-save the game over and over every month.
2024-07-10	Ev*****	Honestly this game was very cool. It was like the basketball one and the football one. The only problem was that the game crashed a lot. I was having fun playing it then it just exited me out the game. So I went back in and it happened again. So the only 2 things the game needs is 1 try to fix the issue with the crashing and 2 at least put the auto save on everyday. But other than that the game has been fun to play but in the next baseball game please make the issue go away. This was a great game it was well made props to them.
Honestly this game was very cool. It was like the basketball one and the football one. The only problem was that the game crashed a lot. I was having fun playing it then it just exited me out the game. So I went back in and it happened again. So the only 2 things the game needs is 1 try to fix the issue with the crashing and 2 at least put the auto save on everyday. But other than that the game has been fun to play but in the next baseball game please make the issue go away. This was a great game it was well made props to them.
2024-06-28	El*****	No delineation between starters and relievers. No true lineup page. Way outdated base rosters. The game is a shell of the hockey format and it’s clear that there was little effort put into this. It’s simply not able to be played in its current state and is far from half baked. Very disappointing.
No delineation between starters and relievers. No true lineup page. Way outdated base rosters. The game is a shell of the hockey format and it’s clear that there was little effort put into this. It’s simply not able to be played in its current state and is far from half baked. Very disappointing.
2024-06-27	bv*****	Might not be perfect yet but is seriously my favorite LM game so far!
Might not be perfect yet but is seriously my favorite LM game so far!
2024-06-23	BD*****	ANOTHER UPDATE: installed the new update. Now I can’t start a season…unless you define watching the “starting your career” screen as playing the career mode. UPDATE: after a few weeks of creating rosters I finally started a career for the first time. Well, tried to start….i move players to the minors and nothing - I tried several times….I also noticed the calendar is crazy - playing a team 10 times in a row?! No ability to set a closer. Crashing randomly. Why put out a game that is clearly not ready/fully playable? I am just not going to play until there are several updates…it’s just frustrating to “play” at this point. I wouldn’t pay for it until the game is playable. I love the games that this developer puts out - amazing ability to fully customize. I was waiting for baseball because it could be awesome. My issues are the following: (1) crashes way too much, (2) can’t differentiate between starters and relievers, (3) needs a better/quicker way to create players - I don’t need pitching rating options for batters and vice versa. Again, love the games - just waiting on improvements for this one. In the meantime, I’m creating the entire 1985 season rosters and real future draft picks!
ANOTHER UPDATE: installed the new update. Now I can’t start a season…unless you define watching the “starting your career” screen as playing the career mode. UPDATE: after a few weeks of creating rosters I finally started a career for the first time. Well, tried to start….i move players to the minors and nothing - I tried several times….I also noticed the calendar is crazy - playing a team 10 times in a row?! No ability to set a closer. Crashing randomly. Why put out a game that is clearly not ready/fully playable? I am just not going to play until there are several updates…it’s just frustrating to “play” at this point. I wouldn’t pay for it until the game is playable. I love the games that this developer puts out - amazing ability to fully customize. I was waiting for baseball because it could be awesome. My issues are the following: (1) crashes way too much, (2) can’t differentiate between starters and relievers, (3) needs a better/quicker way to create players - I don’t need pitching rating options for batters and vice versa. Again, love the games - just waiting on improvements for this one. In the meantime, I’m creating the entire 1985 season rosters and real future draft picks!