Reviews of Hero Making Tycoon Idle Games

By: TapNation App

List of user reviews and ratings for Hero Making Tycoon Idle Games

Total ratings

4.80 (Rating count: 31,108)

Receive review notifications

Get notified when new reviews are posted so you can respond quickly.

See reviews on Apple App Store

View and respond to reviews directly on the store page.

Visit

Review summary

Users generally praise the game for being fun, cute, and easy to pick up, with potato-themed characters, skins, and pets. However, widespread ad-based monetization, a perceived pay-to-win progression, onboarding friction with long tutorials and spammy pop-ups, and account/subscription issues (missing deliveries and lack of cloud save) are common complaints. Some players also cite scams related to offer walls. Overall, the title is enjoyable for many, but aggressive monetization and onboarding problems limit long-term engagement for a portion of users.

Pros

Fun and engaging gameplay
Adorable potato-themed characters with skins and pets
Easy to learn and play; kid-friendly and approachable
Good value with affordable items and cosmetics

Cons

Excessive ads and ad-supported rewards across the game

Upgrade to see all 55 reviews

User Reviews

Recent rating average: 2.60

All time rating average: 4.80

Upgrade to see all 55 reviews

27% (15)

Date	Author	Comment
2026-08-04	jx*****	Very time consuming
Very time consuming
2026-07-07	Up*****	Bad copy
Bad copy
2026-06-30	Si*****	Switched phones and lost everything I payed for. Crazy game but fun. If u can fix it 5 star.
Switched phones and lost everything I payed for. Crazy game but fun. If u can fix it 5 star.
2026-06-21	Pe*****	This game starts kind of slow but picks up and gets really fun
This game starts kind of slow but picks up and gets really fun
2026-05-13	St*****	This game has pretty good dynamics and is fun to play for about an hour before you’re stalled unless you want to watch ads. And this game has ad boosted play in nearly every aspect. I’m not kidding. There are ads for recruiting heroes, ads for resources, ads for chests, ads for speed ups, ads for getting the rewards for your own achievements, ads for energy, ads for currency, ads for strength boosts, add for the wheel spin, ads to gain all rewards in a pick one of three game, ads to keep your rewards in a tarot card game, ads for pets, ads to just in general play the game. Unlike other idle games, there’s no casual way to advance without watching the ads. You either watch the game go static or you watch ads for everything you could possibly need to advance. Not a well-balanced game for people who don’t want to spend the whole game watching ads. Of course, this is probably to annoy you into paying $10-$20 into a pay to play style of not watching the ads, but to me, the point of an idle game is for casual play. The game should be enjoyable or at least PLAYABLE without ads.
This game has pretty good dynamics and is fun to play for about an hour before you’re stalled unless you want to watch ads. And this game has ad boosted play in nearly every aspect. I’m not kidding. There are ads for recruiting heroes, ads for resources, ads for chests, ads for speed ups, ads for getting the rewards for your own achievements, ads for energy, ads for currency, ads for strength boosts, add for the wheel spin, ads to gain all rewards in a pick one of three game, ads to keep your rewards in a tarot card game, ads for pets, ads to just in general play the game. Unlike other idle games, there’s no casual way to advance without watching the ads. You either watch the game go static or you watch ads for everything you could possibly need to advance. Not a well-balanced game for people who don’t want to spend the whole game watching ads. Of course, this is probably to annoy you into paying $10-$20 into a pay to play style of not watching the ads, but to me, the point of an idle game is for casual play. The game should be enjoyable or at least PLAYABLE without ads.
2026-05-07	ki*****	This game is fun but you can’t listen to music while playing it which makes it much less enjoyable. It will constantly pause Apple Music no matter what you do.
This game is fun but you can’t listen to music while playing it which makes it much less enjoyable. It will constantly pause Apple Music no matter what you do.
2026-05-02	ad*****	This game is nothing but ads. Run.
This game is nothing but ads. Run.
2026-04-28	Yu*****	Love it
Love it
2026-04-27	xX*****	I think the game should be more engaging at the start with out so many pop ups and making things show up when you unlock them. I also think that grinding at a low level should be less difficult dont get me wrong it’s not hard it’s just not as engaging as other games that are out there which makes me not want to spend money which is the whole point
I think the game should be more engaging at the start with out so many pop ups and making things show up when you unlock them. I also think that grinding at a low level should be less difficult dont get me wrong it’s not hard it’s just not as engaging as other games that are out there which makes me not want to spend money which is the whole point
2026-04-03	c1*****	Game’s just bad, too many ads and P2W, don’t become a whale to it
Game’s just bad, too many ads and P2W, don’t become a whale to it