Reviews of ManaBox MTG

By: SkillDevs SC App

List of user reviews and ratings for ManaBox MTG

Total ratings

4.34 (Rating count: 9,749)

Receive review notifications

Get notified when new reviews are posted so you can respond quickly.

See reviews on Google Play Store

View and respond to reviews directly on the store page.

Visit

Review summary

ManaBox MTG is praised for fast, user-friendly card scanning and solid collection/deck management, with good value in both free and premium tiers. However, reviews repeatedly flag scanning reliability, subscription-based pricing, and a less intuitive UI, suggesting improvements in scan accuracy, payment options, and navigation would broaden its appeal.

Pros

Fast, easy card scanning that makes it quick to add new cards.
User-friendly UI and overall ease of use.
Strong value for large MTG collections and deck/trade management.
Premium upgrade is seen as worthwhile for advanced features and large collections.

Cons

Scanner reliability and accuracy can be inconsistent; cards can be misread or require manual adjustments.
Recurring subscription pricing is a major gripe; users prefer a one-time unlock or alternative payment methods.
UI/UX can be unintuitive or feel clunky; navigation and interactions could be improved.

Upgrade to see all 267 reviews

User Reviews

Recent rating average: 3.70

All time rating average: 4.34

Upgrade to see all 267 reviews

11% (30)

Date	Author	Comment
2026-08-15	*****	app doesnt work at all. Have a card on a plain white paper background with good ambient lighting and no glare. Doesn't scan any cards at any distance.
app doesnt work at all. Have a card on a plain white paper background with good ambient lighting and no glare. Doesn't scan any cards at any distance.
2026-08-14	Ma*****	Imagine Moxfield, then make the UI a thousand times better, and add like all the customization options. That's manabox.
Imagine Moxfield, then make the UI a thousand times better, and add like all the customization options. That's manabox.
2026-08-14	Ir*****	Detection is extremely poor, feels like it's just picking cards at random. And not only is everything useful paywalled, it's paywalled behind a subscription service with ads for the subscription EVERYWHERE. Almost every button you press just pops up an advertisement for a subscription. Dev response is nonsense - most developers I know don't need an annoying subscription service paywall to keep developing their projects. Overall terrible, just list collection manually in a text file. Useless app.
Detection is extremely poor, feels like it's just picking cards at random. And not only is everything useful paywalled, it's paywalled behind a subscription service with ads for the subscription EVERYWHERE. Almost every button you press just pops up an advertisement for a subscription. Dev response is nonsense - most developers I know don't need an annoying subscription service paywall to keep developing their projects. Overall terrible, just list collection manually in a text file. Useless app.
2026-08-12	Da*****	Flawless, has everything I could ask for, no better way to track your collection. Could use a "suggested resale value" or something similar to give an estimate of what a card should be worth when selling to a shop.
Flawless, has everything I could ask for, no better way to track your collection. Could use a "suggested resale value" or something similar to give an estimate of what a card should be worth when selling to a shop.
2026-08-12	Si*****	Great application, all my decks are available to look at
Great application, all my decks are available to look at
2026-08-11	Ch*****	I'd love to pay for this app, but it's priced more than my cloud storage. I'd be down for 1€/month, but 3€+ is way too much.
I'd love to pay for this app, but it's priced more than my cloud storage. I'd be down for 1€/month, but 3€+ is way too much.
2026-08-10	Je*****	a great way to itemize your Magic collection. I love watching my collection grow in value in real time and have an easy way to refer to the ruling on a card, all in the same place.
a great way to itemize your Magic collection. I love watching my collection grow in value in real time and have an easy way to refer to the ruling on a card, all in the same place.
2026-08-09	An*****	works great
works great
2026-08-08	Za*****	the ui is absolutely horrendous to navigate. everything doesn't make sense. scanner doesn't work very well. everything is cluttered and doesn't make sense at first. their system doesn't work. save yourself some time and use another app.
the ui is absolutely horrendous to navigate. everything doesn't make sense. scanner doesn't work very well. everything is cluttered and doesn't make sense at first. their system doesn't work. save yourself some time and use another app.
2026-08-08	Da*****	would like to see an option to scan proxy cards. other than that it's awesome.
would like to see an option to scan proxy cards. other than that it's awesome.