Reviews of Mythical Society

By: Mythical App

List of user reviews and ratings for Mythical Society

Total ratings

4.40 (Rating count: 342)

Receive review notifications

Get notified when new reviews are posted so you can respond quickly.

See reviews on Apple App Store

View and respond to reviews directly on the store page.

Visit

Review summary

Users praise Mythical Society content and value the membership, and appreciate the redesign's improved navigation and easier access to videos and playlists. However, recurring issues plague the app: frequent sign-in and logout problems, crashes and glitches, and a painful onboarding flow with no in-app signup. Feature gaps such as no auto-play next video and no picture-in-picture hinder multitasking. Casting and AirPlay can be unreliable, and some UI/UX aspects feel rough or like a web wrapper. Overall, content earns high marks, but app stability and usability need substantial improvement.

Pros

High-quality Mythical Society content; videos valuable for members.
Content is worth the extra you pay for membership.
New redesign improves navigation and makes videos and playlists easier to access.
Overall positive as a companion app to Mythical content.

Cons

Frequent sign-in/out issues and not staying signed in; constant login prompts frustrate usage.
Crashes and glitches; the app is unreliable and crashes regularly.
In-app sign-up isn't available; signing up on the website or via a web portal is confusing.
Missing core features like auto-play next video and picture-in-picture for multitasking.
Casting/AirPlay can be unreliable and the UI/UX feels rough, like a web wrapper.

Upgrade to see all 51 reviews

User Reviews

Recent rating average: 2.50

All time rating average: 4.40

Upgrade to see all 51 reviews

24% (12)

Date	Author	Comment
2026-05-02	An*****	I try to make a new account where I don’t have to pay. I think it called initiate or something. When I try to make an account clicking signup does nothing and it just forces me to spend $5 a month. How to fix please
I try to make a new account where I don’t have to pay. I think it called initiate or something. When I try to make an account clicking signup does nothing and it just forces me to spend $5 a month. How to fix please
2026-04-21	Au*****	The app freezes and won’t open. Too much hassle.
The app freezes and won’t open. Too much hassle.
2026-04-12	Su*****	Not sure if this is a feature only for all access but would greatly appreciate the ability to watch videos with picture in picture. I wanna be able to text and or scroll through other apps while still watching content. My ADHD cant let me sit there watching one video playing and no other stims. Please help!
Not sure if this is a feature only for all access but would greatly appreciate the ability to watch videos with picture in picture. I wanna be able to text and or scroll through other apps while still watching content. My ADHD cant let me sit there watching one video playing and no other stims. Please help!
2026-04-11	ka*****	I can’t pay to join so plz give an option for us to join for free!
I can’t pay to join so plz give an option for us to join for free!
2026-01-14	re*****	The content is worth the extra you pay to be a society member, but the app is lacking. My biggest complaint is that there is no auto play feature where the next video automatically plays. I hate to leave such a harsh review but since it’s something a lot of us pay extra for I wish they would put a little more work into it.
The content is worth the extra you pay to be a society member, but the app is lacking. My biggest complaint is that there is no auto play feature where the next video automatically plays. I hate to leave such a harsh review but since it’s something a lot of us pay extra for I wish they would put a little more work into it.
2026-01-08	MJ*****	I love the content I get by being a mythical society member but I honestly don’t go on the app very often because of the constant login process. If I click the back button or close out the app and go back to it 5 minutes later it logs me out. Very frustrating so I don’t go to the app very often even though I pay for 3rd degree membership. If it wasn’t for the quarterly items I wouldn’t have a membership just because the app itself with the format and problems just doesn’t make it worth $55 every 3 months. I wish the app would stay signed in
I love the content I get by being a mythical society member but I honestly don’t go on the app very often because of the constant login process. If I click the back button or close out the app and go back to it 5 minutes later it logs me out. Very frustrating so I don’t go to the app very often even though I pay for 3rd degree membership. If it wasn’t for the quarterly items I wouldn’t have a membership just because the app itself with the format and problems just doesn’t make it worth $55 every 3 months. I wish the app would stay signed in
2025-10-15	Ja*****	It holds your positions in videos, makes watching these two very simplistic and easy. 10/10 recommend.
It holds your positions in videos, makes watching these two very simplistic and easy. 10/10 recommend.
2025-02-20	Te*****	I can't for the life of me find the Think It, Sink It Trivia Game on the app. Where is it???
I can't for the life of me find the Think It, Sink It Trivia Game on the app. Where is it???
2025-01-28	Ni*****	There's a log in button, but no way to sign up. Visiting the website just redirects me to the app, so I can't even see if the website allows signing up.
There's a log in button, but no way to sign up. Visiting the website just redirects me to the app, so I can't even see if the website allows signing up.
2025-01-19	ha*****	I can use Netflix and YouTube to cast to my tv but every time I try to use this app it won’t work. I’ve turned my phone off and on deleted and redownloaded the app it still glitches. I pay for the society member ship so it would be more worth it if the app worked correctly
I can use Netflix and YouTube to cast to my tv but every time I try to use this app it won’t work. I’ve turned my phone off and on deleted and redownloaded the app it still glitches. I pay for the society member ship so it would be more worth it if the app worked correctly