Reviews of Castle War: Idle Island

By: Plug In Digital

List of user reviews and ratings for Castle War: Idle Island

Total ratings

4.04 (Rating count: 2,372)

Receive review notifications

Get notified when new reviews are posted so you can respond quickly.

See reviews on Google Play Store

View and respond to reviews directly on the store page.

Visit

Review summary

Castle War: Idle Island is praised for its fun, strategic gameplay, easy-to-learn mechanics, and replayability. Players enjoy the graphics and find it possible to play without spending money. However, common complaints include long timers, slow progression, frustrating reward systems, buggy targeting mechanics, and occasional crashes. Some feel the game has too many ads and pay-to-win tendencies. Overall, it is considered a good time killer with room for improvement, especially in technical stability and progression balance.

Pros

Fun and strategic gameplay with good replayability
Easy to learn but offers depth for mastery
Not heavily pay-to-win; can be played without spending money
Enjoyable graphics and art style
Reasonable monetization with mostly optional ads

Cons

Long timers and slow progression that feel grindy
Chest/reward system is frustrating with low-tier or repeated rewards
Targeting mechanics for siege weapons are flawed, often misfiring
Bugs causing crashes, lost purchases, and tutorial issues
Excessive ads and pay-to-win elements frustrate some players

Upgrade to see all 70 reviews

User Reviews

Recent rating average: 3.30

All time rating average: 4.04

Upgrade to see all 70 reviews

16% (11)

Date	Author	Comment
2026-03-17	Ju*****	Man is this game shutdown also... From castle siege, now this!? So sad.. This once my fav game
Man is this game shutdown also... From castle siege, now this!? So sad.. This once my fav game
2026-02-26	DE*****	doesn't work! connecting to server..........................
doesn't work! connecting to server..........................
2025-10-27	Gh*****	Sucks!!!
Sucks!!!
2025-09-25	Ti*****	At first I loved the gameplay. Even made a small purchase. However later in the game you will find yourself with little motivation to play more. After special missions are done (only 3 in the game), standard gameplay is boring and repetitive. You play random generated ai, usually very samey. There is no story or other play mode apart from a limited Pvp...The dev does not update with new content so essentially a dead game with no long term attraction.
At first I loved the gameplay. Even made a small purchase. However later in the game you will find yourself with little motivation to play more. After special missions are done (only 3 in the game), standard gameplay is boring and repetitive. You play random generated ai, usually very samey. There is no story or other play mode apart from a limited Pvp...The dev does not update with new content so essentially a dead game with no long term attraction.
2025-07-14	Ro*****	Great
Great
2025-06-18	Jo*****	honestly, I liked the old version better. however, I do like some things in the new version. I do not like that I mostly fight bots and make things worse. The bots I fight are 10+ lvls higher than me, so I end up losing more than I win, which I think is an unfair advantage. It almost seems like they are trying to make you buy more things in the game. All in all, it is fun to play, but they need to work out the bugs.
honestly, I liked the old version better. however, I do like some things in the new version. I do not like that I mostly fight bots and make things worse. The bots I fight are 10+ lvls higher than me, so I end up losing more than I win, which I think is an unfair advantage. It almost seems like they are trying to make you buy more things in the game. All in all, it is fun to play, but they need to work out the bugs.
2025-06-12	JR*****	Pretty entertaining, though each battle only gives little chest points and long upgrade time.
Pretty entertaining, though each battle only gives little chest points and long upgrade time.
2025-02-28	Al*****	Very 👍
Very 👍
2025-02-18	To*****	It's a good thing for you and your family to see your own research and make it a great game
It's a good thing for you and your family to see your own research and make it a great game
2025-01-24	Ja*****	Great game
Great game