Reviews of Cardly AI: Sports Card Scanner

By: Scate App

List of user reviews and ratings for Cardly AI: Sports Card Scanner

Total ratings

4.73 (Rating count: 12,624)

Receive review notifications

Get notified when new reviews are posted so you can respond quickly.

See reviews on Google Play Store

View and respond to reviews directly on the store page.

Visit

Review summary

The app is praised for its ease of use and AI-based valuation features, with some users calling it among the best card apps. However, frequent complaints focus on the expensive subscription model, lack of a true free option, inconsistent/inaccurate valuations, slow performance, and feature limits for non-paying users, along with difficulties canceling and obtaining refunds.

Pros

Easy to use / user-friendly interface.
Price estimates and AI-based valuations available via scans.
Positive sentiment from some users who consider it among the best card apps / a great app / perfect

Cons

Expensive subscription with no clear free trial; multiple mentions of high price and recurring charges.
Valuations and AI grading are inconsistent or inaccurate.
Slow performance and sometimes unreliable results (scans vary for the same card).
Free-use is limited (cannot add cards to collection or perform unlimited scans without paying).
Cancellation/refund difficulties and lack of easy customer support contact.

Upgrade to see all 351 reviews

User Reviews

Recent rating average: 4.50

All time rating average: 4.73

Upgrade to see all 351 reviews

36% (128)

Date	Author	Comment
2026-07-22	Ba*****	easy to use works well
easy to use works well
2026-07-22	Ne*****	I have to say, this is smooth 👌
I have to say, this is smooth 👌
2026-07-22	le*****	I lost 3300 scanned cards when my phone was hacked. do you have a place where they are stored
I lost 3300 scanned cards when my phone was hacked. do you have a place where they are stored
2026-07-22	An*****	So far so good 👍
So far so good 👍
2026-07-21	Ni*****	awsome
awsome
2026-07-21	Gi*****	it's amazing 👏 so far so good💯
it's amazing 👏 so far so good💯
2026-07-21	St*****	Seems fine but confused. I scanned a 2000 Playoff Contenders Rookie Ticket Tom Brady twice. Came up with 2 prices. from $65 to over $4k. It was sold to me as a reprint. these scanners can't distinguish between a reprint and the real card? Maybe I'm asking too much
Seems fine but confused. I scanned a 2000 Playoff Contenders Rookie Ticket Tom Brady twice. Came up with 2 prices. from $65 to over $4k. It was sold to me as a reprint. these scanners can't distinguish between a reprint and the real card? Maybe I'm asking too much
2026-07-21	Ru*****	bought one year subscription and on a brand new card straight out the package low ballin my grade. crisp brand new card says surface scratches frayed corners rough edges basically graded me a 6 on new card. on top of that it takes longer than a min to scan, only to get a low grade on the scan. 40 dollars I'll never get back. app is a joke....don't waste your money on this one! At least read some reviews...had i read reviews first never would have bought it. the grading is 6,7,or 8 everytime
bought one year subscription and on a brand new card straight out the package low ballin my grade. crisp brand new card says surface scratches frayed corners rough edges basically graded me a 6 on new card. on top of that it takes longer than a min to scan, only to get a low grade on the scan. 40 dollars I'll never get back. app is a joke....don't waste your money on this one! At least read some reviews...had i read reviews first never would have bought it. the grading is 6,7,or 8 everytime
2026-07-20	Mi*****	awesome
awesome
2026-07-20	Je*****	Best tool I've seen since card collecting for over 40 yrs
Best tool I've seen since card collecting for over 40 yrs