Highlights transphobic/anti-LGBT and trans-friendly subreddits/users/facebook pages/groups with different colors.
Total ratings
3.95
(Rating count:
300)
Review summary
Pros
- Initially helpful for identifying transphobic accounts and content
- Works well for marking some clearly transphobic users
- Useful for certain periods, assisting users in navigating online communities
Cons
- High rate of false flagging, targeting pro-trans individuals and intersex advocates
- Bias against transmasculine and non-binary individuals, marking them as transphobic
- Lack of context for flagged users, making it unreliable
- Moderators perceived as endorsing discriminatory rhetoric
Most mentioned
- Issues with false flagging
- Concerns about bias against intersex and trans men
- Criticism of the moderation team and their responses
- Increased use as a tool for infighting within the trans community
Upgrade to see all 249 reviews
User reviews
Recent rating average:
1.00
All time rating average:
3.95
Upgrade to see all 249 reviews
Rating filters
5 star 4 star
3 star
2 star
1 star
Date | Author | Rating | Lang | Comment |
---|---|---|---|---|
2024-12-16 | Adrian Bourceanu | |||
2024-12-16 | Sophie Baybey! | en | Extension has become unreliable due to false flagging. Very unhappy with the direction it has gone. | |
2024-12-15 | Celeste | en | Extension is useless due to false flagging and bad faith usage. | |
2024-12-15 | Dosh | en | you became the very thing it fought against. you can't act like you're against transphobia and then target gender identities you don't like or just PEOPLE you don't like. grow up. | |
2024-12-15 | Momo Saitou | en | I as a transgender person have been using Shinigami Eyes for YEARS now, always believing it to be a fair-natured and helpful application for sorting through transphobic blogs and accounts that may not make it evident on the surface, especially anti-trans blogs of the radical feminist flavor. Now, however, I have seen it be used as a weapon against legitimate pro-trans advocates and blogs for, supporting the "wrong kind of trans people" [Trans men/mascs, trans women/fems who support trans men/mascs, intersex people [including intersex trans people] and nonbinary trans people] or for "saying the 'wrong' things"[advocating for intersex people, trans men/mascs, and nonbinary people] It is not a secret that radical feminism has infiltrated many online pro-trans spaces and the community trans people themselves- thus leading us to the volatile situation we now find ourselves in. This application is no longer reliable or safe for those who do not fit into a hyper-specific category of trans people; as even pro-trans non-exclusionist trans women/fems are being marked as red for the "crime of supporting trans men/mascs" . Seeing the response by the moderators to the rightful criticism they have received - boiling down to: "Sorry we don't see anything wrong with blatant intersexism, anti-transmasculintiy , or exorsexism and we will continue to enable people to misuse our application" has fully convinced me that this is not worth the time to even consider trusting. Even trans women [ the group they claim to so dutifully support ] are being marked red and are now being opened to transmisogynistic harassment at the hands of other people who still trust this application. You are enabling the harassment and abuse of countless pro-trans activists by allowing bad actors to control your application. The response by the moderators makes me believe they endorse this radical feminist rhetoric in some way, and thus making this not worth the time of anyone who actually cares about the trans community. | |
2024-12-14 | Berry Blue | en | Well shinigami eyes, i think you're well overdue to be euthanized for falsely flagging people. time to take you out behind the barn put you down. | |
2024-12-14 | solar system | en | Was useful for a while but whoever's currently running it has a nasty habit of approving false reports marking intersex people and advocates as anti-trans - to the point where if you see someone marked in red it's fully a coinflip as to whether they're a TERF or literally just intersex. Haven't used it in ages since then, as it's ceased to become a useful tool for me. (I've also seen a few outright genocidal people marked as green - not Jewish people in general, specifically those in the business of outright demonizing Palestinians and denying genocide. I understand the point of the extension as stated is ONLY to indicate if someone is trans-friendly or not, but I'd appreciate at least not marking them in a color at all instead of telling me they've passed the vibe check? Being trans-friendly does not matter to me if you want Muslim people dead.) | |
2024-12-14 | Kay Husky | en | This extension worked well for the year I've been using it, however lately there's been a rampant use of falsely marking trans people/allies as red. I understood if some false markings slipped through the cracks by the moderators but this is happening way to frequent for it to be accidental at this point. Looking it up online about this issue results in discussion of this extension marking anything related to transmasculine or intersex issues as red. This is something I do not support as a trans individual (FtM), and won't be using this extension anymore until the moderators comes to their senses and fix this issue. | |
2024-12-14 | Candicane Kitkat | en | hey why are the mods marking people talking about INTERSEX GENITAL MUTILATION as anti-trans? is it not enough to face a constant, unending genocide in the form of routine sterilizations? | |
2024-12-14 | Wither | en | was great for awhile, then the mods decided to start being intersexist and the like, so now its pretty worthless |
Upgrade to see all 249 reviews